‘What makes you so special?’ Tory turns on MP Stella Creasy over ban on bringing her son to work

, ‘What makes you so special?’ Tory turns on MP Stella Creasy over ban on bringing her son to work, The Today News USA

Labour’s Stella Creasy was facing a backlash today after she complained about being censured by Parliamentary authorities for taking part in a Commons debate while carrying her young son.

The Walthamstow MP hit out last night after she received an official rebuke for carrying 13-week-old son Pip in a sling during a discussion on Black Friday regulations. 

She has previously taken part in debates in the Commons chamber while carrying one of her two children, and following the 2019 election was sworn in while carrying daughter Hettie. 

Last night’s row prompted Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle to today launch a probe into the rules barring MPs from bringing their children into work. 

But Ms Creasy was criticised by Red Wall Tory MP Scott Benton, who questioned why she needed to bring her son to work. 

‘Parents who get paid a fraction of what you do pay for childcare and juggle responsibilities so they can go to work,’ the Blackpool South MP said. 

‘What makes you so special?’  

, ‘What makes you so special?’ Tory turns on MP Stella Creasy over ban on bringing her son to work, The Today News USA

, ‘What makes you so special?’ Tory turns on MP Stella Creasy over ban on bringing her son to work, The Today News USA

Ms Creasy was criticised by Red Wall Tory MP Scott Benton, who questioned why she needed to bring her son to work.

, ‘What makes you so special?’ Tory turns on MP Stella Creasy over ban on bringing her son to work, The Today News USA

, ‘What makes you so special?’ Tory turns on MP Stella Creasy over ban on bringing her son to work, The Today News USA

The Walthamstow MP took part in a debate on the promotion and regulation of financial products on Black Friday with son Pip in a sling

, ‘What makes you so special?’ Tory turns on MP Stella Creasy over ban on bringing her son to work, The Today News USA

, ‘What makes you so special?’ Tory turns on MP Stella Creasy over ban on bringing her son to work, The Today News USA

 

, ‘What makes you so special?’ Tory turns on MP Stella Creasy over ban on bringing her son to work, The Today News USA

, ‘What makes you so special?’ Tory turns on MP Stella Creasy over ban on bringing her son to work, The Today News USA

Commons Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle announced he has asked a committee to examine the regulations after Stella Creasy was admonished in a letter last night.

, ‘What makes you so special?’ Tory turns on MP Stella Creasy over ban on bringing her son to work, The Today News USA

, ‘What makes you so special?’ Tory turns on MP Stella Creasy over ban on bringing her son to work, The Today News USA

While taking part in the event she was accompanied by Pip, who is still breastfeeding, and received the terse email afterwards.

What are the rules for MPs who are new mums and dads? 

All MPs have to follow the Rules of Behaviour and Courtesies in the House of Commons, which was most recently updated in September. 

Under the section on children it states: ‘You may take babies or toddlers with you into the division lobby, and – if necessary to get to the division lobby – take them through the Chamber. 

‘For safety reasons, you are asked to carry your child and not to bring pushchairs through the lobby. 

‘You should not take your seat in the Chamber when accompanied by your child, nor stand at either end of the Chamber, between divisions.’

However, Ms Creasy and other new mothers in Parliament have previously carried their newborn children – who are often still breastfeeding – into the Commons for debates, with authorities taking a sympathetic stance until now. 

The situation is further complicated because of the rules covering maternity leave. 

MPs can take time off on full pay as they are regarded as self-employed.  Butthey have argued that this means they are unable to take part in votes and debates when they should be representing constituents.

Earlier this year the Government changed legislation to ensure Cabinet ministers received six months maternity leave, to allow the Attorney General, Suella Braverman, to keep her post after having a baby.

But backbench MPs have not been afforded access to the same arrangement. 

In 2019, the Labour MP for Walthamstow took part in a pilot programme which meant when she was pregnant with her first child, she was replaced by a locum who covered the role while she was on leave. 

The post came with £50,000 pro rata salary and covered a period of seven months absence.

They were able to meet ministers and handle casework, but could not vote or speak in the Commons.

But this summer Ms Creasy was told by Parliamentary authorities that she could not appoint a locum MP to cover her second child. 

Instead she was was offered £35,000 to hire a new junior staff member or promote an existing member of her team. 

Ms Creasy said Ipsa have never justified the discontinuation of this pilot project.

<!—->
Advertisement

Ms Creasy tweeted a photograph of an email addressed to her apparently from the Private Secretary to the Chairman of Ways and Means reminding her of the Rules of behaviour and courtesies in the House of Commons, which were updated in early September. 

Paragraph 42 of the Rules states an MP ‘should not take your seat in the Chamber when accompanied by a child’, with the Private Secretary telling the 44-year-old mother of two this also applies to Westminster Hall.

The Walthamstow MP took part in a debate on the promotion and regulation of financial products on Black Friday in the building, the oldest part of the Westminster estate which is used for additional discussions outside the Commons chamber. 

While taking part in the event she was accompanied by Pip, who is still breastfeeding, and received the terse email afterwards. 

Sir Lindsay told MPs: ‘It is extremely important that parents of babies and young children are able to participate fully in the work of this House.’

He said he had been unaware of the advice given to Labour’s Stella Creasy, who was told she can no longer bring her three-month-old son into the Commons chamber, but it ‘correctly reflects the current rules’.

‘However, rules have to be seen in context and they change with the times,’ he said. 

Ms Creasy said she was ‘pleased to hear this’, adding:  ‘(I) Hope this means some of these rules will be reviewed to make parenting and politics possible to mix.’

, &#8216;What makes you so special?&#8217; Tory turns on MP Stella Creasy over ban on bringing her son to work, The Today News USA

All MPs have to follow the Rules of Behaviour and Courtesies in the House of Commons, which was most recently updated in September. 

Under the section on children it states: ‘You may take babies or toddlers with you into the division lobby, and – if necessary to get to the division lobby – take them through the Chamber. 

‘For safety reasons, you are asked to carry your child and not to bring pushchairs through the lobby. 

‘You should not take your seat in the Chamber when accompanied by your child, nor stand at either end of the Chamber, between divisions.’

However, Ms Creasy and other new mothers in Parliament have previously carried their newborn children – who are often still breastfeeding – into the Commons for debates, with authorities taking a sympathetic stance until now. 

‘Mothers in the mother of all parliament are not to be seen or heard it seems…. #21stCenturyCalling,’ Ms Creasy posted with the photographed email on Tuesday afternoon.

In a separate post, Ms Creasy urged support for an campaign to get more mothers involved in politics.

‘Other countries show it doesn’t have to be this way – If you want things to change so politics and parenting can mix, please join our project to help directly support mums of young children to stand for office.’

The BBC cited the House of Commons as saying it was ‘in communication’ with Ms Creasy.

Labour’s Liz Kendall, 50, to ‘step back’ from MP role to become a mother

Leicester West MP Liz Kendall said she will be stepping back from her parliamentary duties and her frontbench role temporarily next year when she has a new baby through surrogacy. 

, &#8216;What makes you so special?&#8217; Tory turns on MP Stella Creasy over ban on bringing her son to work, The Today News USA

, &#8216;What makes you so special?&#8217; Tory turns on MP Stella Creasy over ban on bringing her son to work, The Today News USA

The shadow minister for social care, who ran for the party leadership in 2015, made the announcement last night.

The Leicester West MP said she and her partner were due to become parents in the new year. 

‘I’ll be taking leave from work to make the most of this precious time with the newest member of our family,’ she told the Leicester Mercury. 

‘But I want to reassure my constituents that my office will remain fully open throughout, and my whole team will continue to provide the very best help and support to local residents.’ 

<!—->
Advertisement

Boris Johnson wants to see ‘further improvements’ on making Parliament family friendly, Downing Street has said.

The Prime Minister’s official spokesman, asked by reporters whether MPs should be allowed to bring their babies into the Commons, said: ‘We completely understand the difficulties faced by MPs who are new mothers, new fathers or adopted parents and Parliament has made some positive changes to becoming more family friendly in recent years, including on proxy voting.

‘We want to make sure that all work places are modern, flexible and fit for parents.

‘This is obviously a matter for the House. I know they have issued a statement on that today, but we very much do want to see further improvements.’

Asked whether that comment was akin to Mr Johnson signalling his support for a change on the baby stance, the No 10 spokesman replied: ‘Like I say, we want the workplace in any circumstances to be modern and flexible and fit for the 21st century.

‘The exact way that operates is rightly a matter for the House.’

This morning Deputy Prime Minister Dominic Raab said he has ‘a lot of sympathy’ for Mr Creasy, telling BBC Breakfast: ‘Quite what the right balance is in terms of the chamber, let me leave that to the House authorities but frankly I’ve got a lot of sympathy for Stella Creasy on all of these things because I’ve seen her with her young child, I’ve seen many other MPs on all sides of the House balancing this, and it’s difficult.

‘I think we do need to make sure our profession is brought into the modern world, the 21st century, and can allow parents to juggle the jobs they do with the family time that they need.’

He said he is a ‘sucker for young kids’ and he would not be bothered giving a speech at the despatch box in their presence, adding: ‘When you see your colleagues with their children, given the rough and tumble of politics, I just always think it brings out the best in people.

‘Whether it’s the right thing in the chamber, there will be different views on that, it will be for the House authorities to decide but it certainly wouldn’t distract me or get in the way of me doing my job.’

In late September, Ms Creasy’s then-newborn was strapped to her as she rose in the chamber to ask Commons Leader Jacob Rees-Mogg to ensure new mothers were supported rather than ‘rebuked’ when returning to Parliament.

Mr Rees-Mogg said in response he thought the rules were ‘perfectly reasonable and entirely in line with the law’. 

Labour MP Alex Davies-Jones last night  described the rule as a ‘complete contradiction’ after she said she received an assurance from Sir Lindsay that she could breastfeed in the chamber.

Caroline Lucas, the Green MP, said the rule is ‘absurd’ and ‘absolutely needs to be challenged’, adding that babies are ‘far less disruptive than many braying backbenchers’.

Ms Creasy had regularly taken her son and previously her daughter Hettie into the Commons chamber.

Neither child had been held by the Speaker, however, unlike in New Zealand in 2019.

Speaker Trevor Mallard attracted global fame as a so-called ‘baby whisperer’ after helping to soothe a colleague’s infant – including rocking, bottle feeding and burping the child – during a debate in the chamber in Wellington.

A year earlier, the country’s prime minister Jacinda Ardern became the first world leader to take their baby on to the floor of the UN General Assembly.

, &#8216;What makes you so special?&#8217; Tory turns on MP Stella Creasy over ban on bringing her son to work, The Today News USA

, &#8216;What makes you so special?&#8217; Tory turns on MP Stella Creasy over ban on bringing her son to work, The Today News USA

Ms Creasy with her newborn in September during a debate where she demanded new mothers were ‘supported’ by Parliament 

, &#8216;What makes you so special?&#8217; Tory turns on MP Stella Creasy over ban on bringing her son to work, The Today News USA

, &#8216;What makes you so special?&#8217; Tory turns on MP Stella Creasy over ban on bringing her son to work, The Today News USA

Following the 2019 election she was sworn in while carrying daughter Hettie in a sling (centre)